Extra Chances

From Game Design Patterns 2.0

Jump to: navigation, search

The possibility to try again when an action provides an unwanted result.

Many games use some for of randomness to determine the outcome of events. This will of course led to unwanted results, and to let players have second (and third etc.) chances some games provide the possibility to try again a limited number of times. This lets players have a greater chance of succeeding when it is deemed most important.

Examples

The basic action for players is Yahtzee is to choose what dice to reroll, and players may do two rerolls. Roll Through the Ages: The Bronze Age uses the same basic mechanic but does not allow rerolls of disaster results. Rerolls are used in Bloodbowl to allow players Extra Chances to try again with certain actions when the first try failed.

Fortune points in the second edition of the roleplaying game Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay gives each player a number of Fortune Points every day in the game world equal to their current number of Fate points. The GURPS roleplaying system in contrast lets players that have characters with the Luck advantage reroll a result every hour of gaming (more often with higher levels of the advantage).

Being able to try the same action again and again is a way to provide Extra Chances. For example, players of Origins: How We Became Human populating the right places can continue to try Domestication attempts as long as they occupy the place and can do the Elder Expenditure action.

Using the pattern

Two main design areas that need to be considered when implementing Extra Chances in a game are which events can be effected and, since Extra Chances can be seen as a Resources, how they can be gained and kept. The more types of events that can be effected the more powerful Extra Chances are, so restricting them is a way to balance player influence. Providing new Extra Chances as gameplay progresses is a form of Rewards and makes the Extra Chances into Renewable Resources.

Simply being able to try the same action again is a way of supporting Extra Chances, and Reversibility is a generic tool for allowing new attempts if previous attempts changed the game state. However, these may not be enough if the game features The Show Must Go On since then events caused by other agents or powers may make additional tries impossible. This can be controlled in Single-Player Games since the system caused all other events but makes the pattern more difficult to provide in Multiplayer Games without resorting to Privileged Abilities, as for example the Luck advantage in GURPS or the Warpriest's Strategy feature in Dungeons & Dragons. If the Extra Chances are shared in Teams, they become Shared Resources and may thereby become a source for Social Dilemmas. An additional consideration is if Extra Chances can be use consecutively, i.e. if players can use an Extra Chance to change the result of an Extra Chance.

There also exists a decision on if the Extra Chances should be on exactly the same game state or just within the same game instances. The former is easily naturally applied on Dice through rerolls, but can equally well be applied on Drawing Stacks by letting players draw another Card or Tile. However, for computer games this can also be provided to players through Save-Load Cycles. Lives is a way of letting players try parts of the game again by respectively letting players continue after failing. While Lives are not compatible with Permadeath, Extra Chances in general can be so, for example through the use of rerolls. The pattern can be used in the same fashion to modulate Player Elimination so players risk being eliminated but can have some possibility of explicitly avoiding it. Levels, Save Points and Instances are all ways to chunk the game challenges into smaller sections that can be tried again and again.

Being able to play the game again is of course a way to have Extra Chances, and that is available in nearly all games. However, for many Puzzles the game challenge consists of finding a trick or specific solution and the game instances are all the same except for the player actions, these games can be said to intentionally use Extra Chances on the game instance level.

Diegetic Aspects

Temporal Consistency can be difficult to maintain in a game with Extra Chances, but can be maintained at least in Asynchronous Multiplayer Games since only the final result needs to be convey to the other players.

Interface Aspects

Except for when instantiated through Save-Load Cycles, Extra Chances need to be presented in user interfaces or as Bookkeeping Tokens but there is also a choice of making the number of Extra Chances each players' has into Public Information or making it secret, creating Asymmetric Information. Games with Cards sometimes have specific Cards that provide Extra Chances - the Get out of Jail Free Card in Monopoly is a well-known example.

Consequences

Extra Chances can be seen as a form of Fudged Results since players have a chance to change the outcome of an action (with a bigger chance of changing it the smaller the likelihood that it would occur to begin with). Given that players cannot determine the new result but rather just use the same random process as was just used, it is however a weak form of Fudged Results. Even so, Extra Chances give players a distinct Freedom of Choice but also requires Resource Management. They also increase players' Determinable Chance to Succeed since the statistically do so if there is any chance to succeed to begin with, and increase Predictable Consequences since used Extra Chances increase any differences in odds, favorable or not. In doing this, it can give them an Exaggerated Perception of Influence as well.

If the events affected by Extra Chances are presented within Game Worlds, the pattern conflicts with a game's Temporal Consistency. The sense of Luck may also suffer in games with Extra Chances since less Luck is required on the side of the player gaining a favorable result, and Luck due to others misfortune are less likely to occur if they have Extra Chances.

Although maybe not good for the chances of finishing in a good position, Extra Chances can let inexperienced players redo mistakes early in the game and can thereby support Smooth Learning Curves.

Relations

Can Instantiate

Exaggerated Perception of Influence, Freedom of Choice, Fudged Results, Resources, Resource Management, Determinable Chance to Succeed, Predictable Consequences, Privileged Abilities, Rewards, Social Dilemmas, Smooth Learning Curves

Can Modulate

Dice, Drawing Stacks, Permadeath, Player Elimination

Can Be Instantiated By

Bookkeeping Tokens, Cards, Instances, Levels, Lives, Puzzles, Reversibility, Save-Load Cycles, Save Points

Can Be Modulated By

Asymmetric Information, Public Information, Renewable Resources

Possible Closure Effects

-

Potentially Conflicting With

Luck, Multiplayer Games, Temporal Consistency, The Show Must Go On

History

New pattern created in this wiki.

References

-

Personal tools